Land Management — Listener Q&A
Questions 1–120 of 305 in this category (page 1 of 3). All listener questions · next →
Herd Management
Question: Dylan asked how Michigan becoming a one-buck state in the Lower Peninsula would change deer hunting and whether it could become a top big-buck competitor. 43:13 — asked by Dylan Wilson — Why Mature Bucks Go Nocturnal | Chasing Giants Podcast 326
- Answer: Don said Michigan’s roughly 600,000 hunters carry generations-old cultural habits, making a quick shift in hunting behavior unlikely despite the new law. 44:14
Question: Jordan Brandenburg asked whether Don and Terry’s farms will ever consistently produce 190-plus bucks with occasional 220s, and what each farm’s ceiling is. 37:40 — asked by Jordan Brandenburg — Permission Properties, Scrape Magnet Explained, and Our Health Journeys | Chasing Giants Ep. 315
- Answer: Don doesn’t think his farm will get there; he believes he’s near his ceiling, which has plateaued since about 2020 with occasional 200-inch bucks. 38:22
Question: Jay Thielen asked whether a proposed Michigan $1 buck tag would improve the state’s deer age structure. 48:23 — asked by Jay Thielen — Permission Properties, Scrape Magnet Explained, and Our Health Journeys | Chasing Giants Ep. 315
- Answer: Don says a one-buck limit would be a strong positive for Michigan’s deer herd quality compared to the current two-tag limit. 49:01
Question: Duane Miller asks how culling the worst bucks on his own property benefits him rather than just his neighbors, given bucks disperse. 29:29 — asked by Duane Miller — Chasing Giants LIVE at the Midwest Sportsmen’s Classic | Shipshewana, IN | Presented by FAE
- Answer: Don says he isn’t too worried since most neighbors won’t follow the same management plan, so he isn’t just benefiting them. 29:43
Question: Terry asks Don to explain his culling philosophy of letting the best bucks in each age class live while removing eight-pointers first. 25:30 — CULLING BUCKS: Why Shooting 3½-Year-Old 8-Points Actually Works | Chasing Giants #310
- Answer: Don explains he began culling roughly twenty years ago, removing the worst bucks in each age class and letting the best ones live, which stopped him losing his top bucks over time. 28:05
Question: How can hunters get more excited about taking more does? 53:36 — LIVE at 360 Blinds: No Script, No Filters — Just Real Questions | Chasing Giants 308
- Answer: Don shares that after shooting far more does, daytime buck activity and rut sign on his farm improved dramatically. 54:05
Question: Terry asks Don to describe how his farm’s buck-to-doe ratio has changed, what it is now, and what he thinks the ideal balance should be. 15:53 — Most Hunters Get This Wrong | The Hard Truth About Killing Mature Bucks | Chasing Giants #307
- Answer: Don reports his buck-to-doe ratio is currently about one-to-one, getting roughly as many buck trail-camera photos as doe photos. 18:24
Question: Terry asks whether Don, given his isolated farm, would prefer a two-to-one buck-to-doe ratio to keep more bucks home. 25:28 — Most Hunters Get This Wrong | The Hard Truth About Killing Mature Bucks | Chasing Giants #307
- Answer: Don says he’s backing off doe harvest and now aims for at least a two-to-one, possibly three-to-one, doe-to-buck ratio. 26:16
Question: Terry asks whether Don would shoot a target buck missing a tine since last seen and have it rebuilt for the mount, or pass him another year. 29:51 — Most Hunters Get This Wrong | The Hard Truth About Killing Mature Bucks | Chasing Giants #307
- Answer: Don says it depends on the specific buck’s age, but the vast majority of the time a buck missing a tine will get a free pass rather than be shot. 30:28
Question: Drew Harmon asks whether hunters are taking their deer herds for granted, given declining public-land quality and liberal buck limits. 34:16 — Most Hunters Get This Wrong | The Hard Truth About Killing Mature Bucks | Chasing Giants #307
- Answer: Don agrees hunters as a whole are short-sighted, prioritizing instant gratification over long-term deer herd management. 35:07
Question: Terry asks Don whether Boone Brothers solves hunters’ moral dilemma of killing does without a good way to use the meat. 9:36 — Kill More Deer. Feed Hungry Kids. | Boone Brothers | Chasing Giants 306
- Answer: Don responds with a challenge: if John can get Boone Brothers working with Illinois’s restrictive nuisance-permit system, he can partner with any state in the country. 11:33
Question: Listener Drew Wright asked the smallest acreage needed to produce and hold mature bucks on an isolated property. 32:53 — asked by Drew Wright — When Managing Deer Means Saying NO to Giants | Chasing Giants Podcast #304
- Answer: Don said 40 acres, managed well with good habitat, could attract and let hunters kill some of the area’s best bucks. 34:00
Question: Listener Jeff Sparks asked what Don thought of allowing party hunting for does only in Illinois. 51:26 — asked by Jeff Sparks — When Managing Deer Means Saying NO to Giants | Chasing Giants Podcast #304
- Answer: Don said he dislikes party hunting entirely, regardless of the doe-only framing. 51:29
Question: Listener Jabin Walker asked what Don does with excess doe meat and for advice on handling surplus harvests. 53:36 — asked by Jabin Walker — When Managing Deer Means Saying NO to Giants | Chasing Giants Podcast #304
- Answer: Don said he processes deer and gives them away to a waiting list of people who ask to be added. 53:54
Question: Luke Yoder asks which state has the greatest potential for producing big bucks but is dropping the ball, especially regarding Michigan. 39:26 — asked by Luke Yoder — Episode 303 – Late-Season Deer Movement, Winter Food Strategy & The Future of Big Bucks
- Answer: Don says Illinois has the greatest potential of any state but has dropped the ball, since it was once the best whitetail state in the country. 39:51
Question: Has Don gathered enough data to decide whether he’ll harvest any more does this season? 32:58 — Late Season EXPLOSION! Why Giants Are Falling Everywhere | Chasing Giants #302
- Answer: Don says he’ll only shoot another doe if she’s accompanied by button bucks. 33:06
Question: Is Indiana’s antlerless-only-tag-restriction rule out of touch, or is it the correct way to protect antlerless deer? 45:18 — asked by Montana Moritz — Late Season EXPLOSION! Why Giants Are Falling Everywhere | Chasing Giants #302
- Answer: Don says the state sets regulations from a broad, statewide view meant to fit most properties on average, not any one specific farm. 46:12
Question: Terry asked what happens if hunters cull too many does — does it reduce the attraction factor that draws bucks during the rut? 17:39 — Late Season Starts NOW — Cold Fronts, Bucks on Food, and Thanksgiving Reflections | Episode #301
- Answer: Don said fewer does makes bucks more active but also pushes them to wander off the property searching for does elsewhere. 18:11
Question: Listener Randall Barr asked what recommendations Don would make for managing for mature bucks, including possible crossbow season date limits. 42:09 — asked by Randall Barr — Late Season Starts NOW — Cold Fronts, Bucks on Food, and Thanksgiving Reflections | Episode #301
- Answer: Don said the key is reducing pressure on younger bucks so more of them survive to older age classes. 42:28
Question: Joe Nelden asks whether bucks passed to reach maturity eventually sense the property isn’t ideal and move on to a better one. 43:50 — asked by Joe Nelden — EPISODE 300! Don Changes His Mind on the Rut + Drone Debate Heats Up!
- Answer: Don explains a mature buck’s top priority is avoiding human intrusion, which is why building a sanctuary is essential to keeping him. 44:40
Question: Alan Glick asks whether shooting does with buck fawns early in archery season helps keep those buck fawns from being pushed out. 50:29 — asked by Alan Glick — EPISODE 300! Don Changes His Mind on the Rut + Drone Debate Heats Up!
- Answer: Don explains research shows that if you shoot a doe, she won’t be there next spring to run off her yearling buck fawns, so they tend to stay nearby. 52:11
Question: Keith Evans asked Don and Terry’s thoughts on banning cell cams and whether they save as many bucks as they kill. 40:02 — asked by Keith Evans — The Weirdest Rut Ever: Warm Temps, Barometers, and Big Bucks | Chasing Giants Ep #298
- Answer: Don disagreed, saying he doesn’t think cell cams save more bucks than they kill, unlike regular cameras that require human intrusion. 40:32
- Answer: Don predicted cell cams will likely never be banned on private land because landowner rights trump such regulation, though public-land bans are plausible. 41:36
Question: Brock asked whether Don and Terry struggle to shoot mature bucks they’ve watched grow up for years, or if he’s just getting soft. 42:36 — asked by Brock Van Oslin — Barometer Secrets & Rut Forecast for Early November! | Chasing Giants 297
- Answer: Don said he now relates to Brock’s dilemma, watching favorite bucks grow up and dreading that shooting them means the story is over. 43:45
Question: Brett Falk asked if killing does to keep buck fawns from dispersing, preventing natural inbreeding avoidance, is counterintuitive to sound herd management. 47:49 — asked by Brett Falk — #294 From Old School to High Tech: Don Higgins Reflects on 40 Years in the Deer Woods
- Answer: Don called it a great observation but said such close inbreeding among buck fawns and does is so infrequent it isn’t consequential to the local deer herd. 48:17
Question: What is Don’s doe strategy on his farm this year, and when will he start harvesting does? 15:38 — #292 - Public Land Busts, Big Timber Dreams, & Target Bucks
- Answer: Don plans to shoot fewer does than last year’s eight, aiming for around four to five this season. 15:57
Question: Why is it important to wait until all the crops come out before assessing doe numbers? 16:09 — #292 - Public Land Busts, Big Timber Dreams, & Target Bucks
- Answer: Because Don’s area is over 90% ag fields, deer live out in the crops all summer and don’t move onto his property much until harvest. 16:20
Question: How is doe timing affected by neighbors having to do late or second plantings this year? 16:57 — #292 - Public Land Busts, Big Timber Dreams, & Target Bucks
- Answer: Don says crops in his neighborhood are drying fast with no rain in the forecast, so he doesn’t expect doe harvest timing to drag out. 17:42
Question: How many cull bucks does Don think he and Corey need to gauge, and will that wait until crops are out? 18:43 — #292 - Public Land Busts, Big Timber Dreams, & Target Bucks
- Answer: Don says there are at least three bucks aged three and older that he’d already give the green light to shoot. 18:52
Question: Does Don seeing more bucks and fewer does this summer support the ‘doe factory’ theory? 48:39 — asked by Michael Raines — #292 - Public Land Busts, Big Timber Dreams, & Target Bucks
- Answer: Don says it has nothing to do with a doe factory; it’s simply a result of how he’s managing the herd. 52:09
- Answer: He still provides the same summer food sources as always; the only change is he now has fewer resident does after heavier doe harvest. 50:07
Question: Dennis Isaacs asks whether to cull a fork-horn or eight-point two-year-old in a one-buck state. 46:02 — asked by Dennis Isaacs — #287 “Predators, Food Plots & Cracker Barrel Woke?
- Answer: Don says he does not advocate culling yearlings or two-year-olds. 46:22
- Answer: Don advises shooting the worst two of the three-year-old bucks and letting the best two live. 48:56
- Answer: Don notes shooting the worst two gives the hunter some influence over which bucks remain. 49:26
Question: Is it more important to remove adult does that may carry big-buck genetics, or protect them so they keep producing potential big bucks? 54:25 — asked by Nick Miller — Episode #281 - How Don Tracks Giant Bucks Years in Advance
- Answer: Don says keeping a doe alive doesn’t help because her buck fawns are likely to disperse miles away anyway, so protecting buck fawns matters more than protecting individual does. 55:13
Question: If a known, marked call buck came by after shedding during late doe season, would you shoot him? 18:26 — #279 - Live Hot Seat! Don Higgins Faces Tough Questions from Dealers | 2025 RWWP Summit
- Answer: Don says he probably would, since if you want the buck out of the herd, you shoot him. 18:35
Question: Eli Doyle asks Don and Terry’s thoughts on the Illinois bill loosening nuisance deer permit rules and what it would take for better deer management practices. 22:54 — asked by Eli Doyle — Episode #273 - Clover Maintenance and Spring Planting
- Answer: Don argues a well-designed management plan could reduce the deer herd to a level tolerable for farmers while still satisfying hunters, rather than the current mismanagement. 28:44
- Answer: Don disputes the bill’s justification, saying the claimed $45,000 crop loss would mean an implausible total wipeout of 45 acres, and doubts it was solely deer damage. 26:42
Question: Jerry Robinson asked what percentage of three-and-a-half-year-old bucks passed become true primary target bucks rather than disappointments. 63:17 — asked by Jerry Robinson — Episode #268 - Thermal Drone Tells the Truth on Don’s Farm
- Answer: Don said very few, probably around 10%, of three-and-a-half-year-old bucks passed end up becoming true target bucks; most get culled instead. 64:03
- Answer: Terry added that the specific three-year-olds they identify and pass usually do end up becoming the shooter buck. 64:17
Question: Jerry Robinson’s second question asked whether Don is still raising the bar on trophy standards or has taken it as far as he ever will. 63:42 — asked by Jerry Robinson — Episode #268 - Thermal Drone Tells the Truth on Don’s Farm
- Answer: Don said no, he’s about as far as he can take it, especially given how state regulations have devastated the Illinois deer herd. 66:08
Question: How detrimental does Don think coon hunting with hounds is to a quality deer property? 38:18 — asked by Troy Hoffman — Episode #262 - The Controlled Burn on Switchgrass GONE BAD!
- Answer: Don says he is not a fan of running dogs on a deer property at all, regardless of training. 39:02
- Answer: Don advises Troy to either give up coon hunting on his deer property or find another place to run his dogs. 39:37
Question: Could state agencies legally limit or ban high fences on private deer properties? 55:05 — asked by Josh Combs — Episode #259 Apple Tree Spacing in Deer Plots
- Answer: Don doubts fence bans could hold up in court given other legal exceptions like security and agricultural fencing. 55:53
- Answer: Don blames poor state game agency management for driving landowners to build fences in the first place. 57:16
Question: Did you meet your doe harvest goals, and when did you focus on thinning the herd? 38:15 — asked by Beckham Pearson — Episode #256 - Hard Winter and Early Buck Shed? Illinois CWD Announcement
- Answer: Don and his guests shot eight does and four bucks — 12 deer total, more than double any previous year on this farm. 38:35
- Answer: Don stopped shooting does at eight because he noticed the larger herds he’d seen earlier in the year had thinned out. 38:57
Question: How many buck fawns does it take to produce one target buck—at least five years old and 180 inches—given predation, mowing, poaching, and hunting mortality? 38:33 — asked by Casey Larson — Episode #252 - Don says, “THERE IS NO SECOND RUT!”
- Answer: Don estimated several thousand buck fawns are born off his farm per buck reaching five years and 180 inches, but his own farm’s management yields far better odds. 41:14
Question: Terry asks whether they’re seeing unusually high deer numbers or simply higher quality bucks on this Mexico hunt. 11:35 — asked by Terry — Episode #251 - Update on Don & Joe Miles Kills 2 Giant Mexico Bucks!
- Answer: Joe says the ranch has a well-balanced age structure, with four-, five-, and six-year-old bucks visible in any given sit, calling it ‘Disney World.’ 12:25
Question: Terry asks Don why a bowhunting podcast, hosted by someone who hasn’t gun hunted in years, decided to partner with a firearm manufacturer. 76:32 — Episode #245 - Halloween Hunting Should Be Great! Weather and Hunting Forecast from Don Higgins
- Answer: Don explains a serious doe overpopulation problem on his farm is pushing him to use a firearm this season for the first time in years. 76:50
- Answer: He adds his grandsons are starting to hunt, and it’s much easier to introduce a youth to hunting with a gun than a bow. 77:21
Question: Austin asked whether Illinois farmers should report deer crop damage to the Farm Bureau/DNR survey or ignore it, given raccoons cause similar damage. 21:57 — asked by Austin — Episode #244 - October Lull? Don and Terry See Bucks Moving in Mid October
- Answer: Don said the Illinois Farm Bureau, tied to insurance interests, has meddled in deer management for decades and is the most powerful lobby in the state. 22:35
- Answer: Don proposed splitting Illinois’ buck season into early and late seasons, requiring a doe be tagged before a hunter can take a second buck, to boost doe harvest. 26:02
Question: Mark asked whether October mornings are a good time to harvest does or if he should wait until later in the season. 45:51 — asked by Mark — Episode #244 - October Lull? Don and Terry See Bucks Moving in Mid October
- Answer: Don said October mornings are fine for shooting does, but where on the property matters more than the time of day. 46:35
Question: Damon Marling asked how giant buck genetics could stay concentrated in certain areas if does drive off their yearling buck offspring to disperse widely. 47:55 — asked by Damon Marling — Episode #242 - Stop Hunting October Mornings
- Answer: Don answered that both genetics and sanctuary, which allows bucks to reach older age, combine to keep giant buck genes concentrated in certain areas. 48:27
Question: Scott Peters from Bartelso, Illinois asks Don and Terry’s opinion on what’s driving high grading and how the trend might be turned around. 30:35 — asked by Scott Peters — Podcast #241 - Don’s Target Buck Revealed - Non-Typical Giant!
- Answer: Don says he’d rather a neighbor shoot the first legal buck and stop hunting, since neighbors who promise to let deer walk often break the agreement and shoot the best one anyway. 31:57
- Answer: Don illustrates high grading with an analogy: given two equally aged bucks, an 8-point scoring 120 and a 10-point scoring 150, hunters almost always shoot the bigger-scoring one. 33:12
Question: Dave Least asks whether it’s better to shoot does early before they’re bred or if timing doesn’t matter. 32:08 — asked by Dave Least — Episode #240 - If Don Was DNR, How He Would Make Illinois Better Than Iowa
- Answer: Don says timing doesn’t affect whether the doe was already bred, but as a land manager it’s better to shoot her early since she’ll have eaten less food. 32:34
Question: Is there anything that can be done to expedite a deer herd’s recovery to a healthy level after a severe EHD outbreak? 28:21 — asked by Rob Vander Venen — Episode #239 - EHD Is Closing in on Don’s Farm!
- Answer: Don said after his 2012 outbreak he stopped shooting does entirely for nearly ten years, only resuming a couple does per year recently. 28:26
Question: Jason Steele asked whether certain small geographic pockets, even within one county, consistently produce bigger bucks regardless of scale. 51:38 — asked by Jason Steele — Episode 238 - 2024 Buck Forecast - MORE GIANTS SHOT THIS YEAR
- Answer: Don attributed the ‘hot pocket’ phenomenon mainly to genetics, since nutrition barely varies across the Midwest’s corn and soybean landscape from mile to mile. 52:51
Question: Justin Sheer asked whether the age class of does harvested actually matters for herd management. 39:45 — asked by Justin Sheer — Episode 228 - Is Iowa Really the Best State?
- Answer: Don dismisses age-based doe selection theories as internet nonsense that sounds good but doesn’t work in practice, since doe age can’t be told by sight. 40:53
Question: Terry asked Don how he decides whether a doe is bedding on his property or a neighbor’s. 41:04 — Episode 228 - Is Iowa Really the Best State?
- Answer: Don says the first criterion is that the doe must be mature. 41:23
- Answer: Don says assuming a doe consistently beds on one property is total nonsense, since she may split time between properties. 41:14
Question: If Justin passes a buck with a possible pedicle injury this year, will his antlers return to normal or stay non-typical? 25:40 — asked by Justin Kenner — Episode #227 - Science Behind Summer Solstice and Whitetail
- Answer: Don explains that if the buck’s pedicle itself was injured, the deer will have a permanently messed-up antler for life. 25:53
Question: An audience member asks how Don and Terry calculate carrying capacity and set doe harvest numbers on their farms and consulting clients’ land. 31:53 — Episode #211 - Live from RWWP Dealer Event - BINGO
- Answer: Don says he gives clients a three-year plan and evaluates the deer herd’s trend before adjusting harvest recommendations. 32:11
- Answer: Bronson Strickland says his team judges recommendations by tracking average doe body weight and carcass condition over time. 34:06
Question: Barry Holt from Gap, Pennsylvania asks what’s more frustrating: a neighbor shooting a buck on your target list, or one you wanted to let grow more years. 51:12 — asked by Barry Holt — Episode 199 - Dewormer in Deer Feed, Tractors, Screens, and Windmills
- Answer: Don says managing for big deer is so competitive that you can’t fully trust a neighbor to honor an agreement not to shoot a target buck. 52:18
- Answer: Terry suggests neighbors sometimes claim they’ll pass a buck partly to gather intel while protecting their own interest in it. 53:08
Question: Nicholas Cross asked whether buck fawns would attach to another doe if their mother were killed, and whether that doe would kick them out. 30:36 — asked by Nicholas Cross — Episode #197 - Don’s Grandson Kills His First Buck!
- Answer: Don said it would be very rare for another doe to fully adopt orphaned buck fawns, and she would not show maternal aggression by kicking them out. 31:07
Question: Terry asked when a fawn actually weans off its mother, a topic they hadn’t discussed before on the podcast. 31:37 — Episode #197 - Don’s Grandson Kills His First Buck!
- Answer: Don said fawns typically wean in late winter, around January, though many are still nursing this time of year. 31:42
- Answer: Don added fawns can generally survive independently by about three months of age, sometimes earlier under ideal conditions. 32:30
Question: Vincent asked whether pushing does out of a sanctuary during the rut so they return with nonlocal bucks would increase huntable bucks on a property. 17:33 — asked by Vincent — Episode 192 - End of October - Tactics and Plans are Changing - PRE RUT!
- Answer: Don calls the idea one of the craziest he’s heard and says it will not happen, since property lines don’t exist in a deer’s world. 19:14
- Answer: Don adds research shows bucks don’t leave familiar areas during the rut even under extreme hunting pressure. 20:02
- Answer: Terry adds that any buck following a returning doe would keep chasing her until pushing her into an isolated remote area, not necessarily the hunter’s property. 20:28
Question: How will Don make the youth hunt a learning experience for his grandsons—showing them deer pictures and teaching about buck management? 9:54 — Episode #190 - Prep for Youth Season - Green Light on Babe
- Answer: Don says they’ll show the boys pictures so they know exactly where to aim on the deer. 10:03
- Answer: Don says they’ll also talk about management, explaining at least 4 bucks on the farm remain off-limits this year. 10:45
Question: If a three-year-old buck with an eight-point rack walks out, would Don still tell the boys not to shoot it? 11:49 — Episode #190 - Prep for Youth Season - Green Light on Babe
- Answer: Don says no; with only a three-day season, they won’t shoot yearling bucks, but a good three-year-old is fair game. 11:58
Question: Carter Lang asks whether letting a grandson shoot the buck Babe could negatively affect the boy’s future passion for hunting. 34:21 — asked by Carter Lang — Episode #189 - Season Opener and Tough Questions
- Answer: Don says the grandsons will get to shoot Babe if he steps out, since Don himself won’t pass on the buck and expects them to follow the same rule. 36:33
Question: Parker Redicker asked whether he should shoot a mature buck whose antler growth declined this year, or let him go hoping for a rebound. 15:08 — asked by Parker Redicker — Episode #187 - Do Trail Camera’s Spook Mature Bucks?
- Answer: Don confirmed that a buck’s antler growth can bounce back in later years. 15:48
- Answer: Don said the shoot-or-pass decision largely depends on the quality of young bucks coming up behind the buck in question. 16:12
- Answer: Don affirmed bucks can rebound and even exceed their previous antler size in later years. 16:42
- Answer: Don added that he plans to have his own buck ‘Babe,’ now six years old, harvested this year given the strong young buck crop behind him. 16:23
Question: Terry asks Don what will happen if one of his grandsons is hunting and Babe walks out at 25 yards. 28:08 — asked by Terry — Episode #182 - Don’s Buck Management Plan for 2023
- Answer: Don deflects, saying it’s a good question they’ll have to think about. 28:18
Question: Tyler Gehrig from Danville, Kansas asked whether Don and Joe would change their target buck size if out-of-state hunters and bait piles degraded deer quality on his property. 41:06 — asked by Tyler Gehrig — Episode #181 - What is new with Asio Gear?
- Answer: Joe noted Kansas’s DNR is considering banning all baiting statewide, which he said he’d welcome. 42:03
- Answer: Joe added that eliminating baiting, while keeping post-season supplemental feeding, would improve deer herds a lot. 42:32
- Answer: Don advised that hunters facing declining deer quality should find solutions rather than make excuses, including moving to better properties. 44:47
Question: Justin from Wild Rose, Wisconsin asked Don and Terry how to guesstimate a buck’s age without prior camera history. 58:16 — asked by Justin — Episode #181 - What is new with Asio Gear?
- Answer: Don explained fall is much easier for aging bucks than summer, since mature bucks’ necks and bodies fill out dramatically. 59:22
- Answer: Joe added that hunters should shoot whatever buck matches their own priorities, regardless of what others think about its age. 62:23
Question: Grant Flipping from Jefferson City, Missouri asked why Missouri, despite bordering top whitetail states, is never mentioned as a hot spot, blaming state mismanagement. 43:59 — asked by Grant Flipping — Episode #176 - Don’s Advice for Battery High Prices
- Answer: Don agreed Missouri’s poor deer management, not habitat, is to blame, citing its rifle season during the rut and lenient crossbow and multi-buck rules. 46:06
Question: Brandon McDaniel asks whether Kentucky should offer an extra buck tag for tagging additional does, per a Fish and Wildlife survey on increasing doe harvest. 47:56 — asked by Brandon McDaniel — Episode #171 - Take What a Property Gives You!
- Answer: Don personally dislikes the bonus-tag-for-does idea, fearing dishonest hunters would falsely claim doe harvests to earn an extra buck tag. 48:39
- Answer: Don says such a system punishes honest hunters while others game it, though he’d support it if the bonus tag were late-season archery only. 49:36
Question: Dan Schultz asks what Don thinks state DNR agencies should manage for—age structure, population numbers, or trophy opportunities. 55:56 — asked by Dan Schultz — Episode #171 - Take What a Property Gives You!
- Answer: Don’s goal for any state is a deer population level acceptable to most of the human population, not maximized purely for farmers or hunters. 56:36
- Answer: Don also wants states to manage for better age structure and more balanced buck-to-doe sex ratios rather than letting buck harvest dominate. 57:26
Question: Taylor Woods asks what factors Don weighs when deciding whether a buck goes on the shooter or pass list. 61:11 — asked by Taylor Woods — Episode #164 - CRP Programs - Know Facts!
- Answer: Don says his shooting criteria change depending on which property he’s hunting, since deer movement and risk differ by farm. 61:55
Question: An anonymous Missouri listener asked whether sanctuaries are best placed in the center, exterior, or a combination on a property. 58:48 — Episode #163 - The Hype of Chestnut Trees…
- Answer: Don said the ideal setup is a sanctuary on one side you can hunt the perimeter of, pulling deer across a transition zone to the other side. 61:05
- Answer: Terry added that knowing what neighboring landowners are doing is a vital piece of deciding where to pull, push, or block deer. 61:47
Question: An audience member asked whether Tennessee’s improving deer herd is from cutting the buck limit from three to two, or just natural growth. 18:28 — Episode 159 - Captive Deer Breeding… Why Don Got Out
- Answer: Don said it’s a combination of factors, including that deer management is catching on and spreading. 18:42
- Answer: Don said the South is roughly a generation behind the Midwest in deer management. 20:15
Question: A Kentucky hunter asked what would make Kentucky the best deer state on the planet. 47:59 — Episode 159 - Captive Deer Breeding… Why Don Got Out
- Answer: Terry said Kentucky’s rifle season should be moved out of the rut. 48:16
- Answer: Terry said limiting out-of-state hunters to a draw system would let much of Kentucky rival any other state. 49:21
Question: Andrew Jones asks if Illinois will become a one-buck state and if the herd must be wiped out before politicians address the 45/55 doe-buck harvest ratio. 34:35 — asked by Andrew Jones — Episode #158 - Is Hunting Contests Hurting the Hunting Industry?
- Answer: Don says neither Illinois politicians nor state deer biologists care about mature deer, and it will never improve; private landowners must manage on their own. 35:32
Question: An audience member asked how important it is to cull older bucks so younger family members can shoot them. 58:27 — Chasing Giants #155 - Hilarious Episode Live from Middlefield, OH
- Answer: Don said his culling approach raised his farm’s top-end buck size by about 20 inches over twenty years. 61:50
Question: Mike Soyster asks whether Don targets a certain buck-to-doe ratio on his property or takes a ‘more the merrier’ approach. 51:05 — asked by Mike Soyster — Episode #153 - What Should Buck Doe Ratio Be?
- Answer: Don says almost no individual landowner controls enough ground to meaningfully influence a buck-to-doe ratio. 51:46
- Answer: Don recommends shooting plenty of does but forgetting about hitting an exact ratio, since it’s unachievable for most landowners. 53:10
Question: Terry asks Don whether he cares more about the number of does shot or which specific does are shot. 53:24 — Episode #153 - What Should Buck Doe Ratio Be?
- Answer: Don says he cares more about which specific does are shot, favoring those with twin buck fawns and older, wiser does. 53:35
Question: Paul asks whether Don still believes the deer herd remains below pre-EHD levels and whether he’s now shooting does on his own farm or for landowners. 44:15 — asked by Paul — Episode #149 Frigid Temps and Deer… Merry Christmas 2022!
- Answer: Don agrees the statewide deer herd remains down on average since the 2012 EHD outbreak. 48:45
- Answer: Don says his own farm has plenty of deer, and doing nothing would let them destroy his habitat and upset his neighbors. 49:11
- Answer: Don says he now feels comfortable shooting a few does on his property, not to reduce the herd but simply to maintain current levels. 50:13
Question: An anonymous listener from Farmville USA asks whether a well-managed property can have an ‘off year’ when good bucks pass through but don’t stay. 20:12 — asked by Anonymous Farmville USA — Episode #148 - Are Bucks Shedding Antlers Early This Year?
- Answer: Don explains that apparent ‘off years’ usually happen because the bucks that would have matured into shooters get killed on neighboring properties first, not because the property failed. 22:58
Question: Alex Bains asks how many bucks per age class is ideal, and what buck-to-doe ratio to target per 100 acres. 53:10 — asked by Alex Bains — Episode #148 - Are Bucks Shedding Antlers Early This Year?
- Answer: Don says there’s no magic number of bucks per age class—he just wants as many yearlings as possible—since every property and surrounding area differs. 56:06
- Answer: Don says buck:doe ratio is largely irrelevant for 99% of land managers whose properties are too small to influence area-wide ratios. 56:35
Question: Peter Shell asked whether Don agreed with Lee Lakosky’s theory that holding late-season bucks until spring green-up encourages them to become permanent residents. 28:39 — Episode #144 - Where Did All The Bucks Go?
- Answer: Don said he does see new bucks show up in late season that return in future years, but his smaller property differs from Lakosky’s larger operation. 30:21
Question: Kirk Stillwell asks: once a clean eight-pointer adds a point like a drop tine as a four-year-old, what are the odds it keeps adding non-typical points as it ages? 40:21 — asked by Kirk Stillwell — Chasing Giants Podcast #141 - Scrapes are hot… So is the weather!
- Answer: Don says the majority of clean, smooth-racked eight-point bucks at three years old stay that way for life, though some do add extra points as they age. 40:40
Question: Carl Parks asked whether bucks can regress in antler size some years and rebound later, citing a buck that got smaller after five years old. 37:36 — asked by Carl Parks — Episode #140 - Fall Drought - What does that mean for deer hunters?
- Answer: Don confirms it’s fairly common for bucks to regress in antler size when they’d be expected to add inches. 37:56
- Answer: Don recalls a buck shot in Clark County, Illinois that scored 214 inches and grew its very best rack at nine and a half years old. 39:05
- Answer: Don says the best antler growth starts with an early spring, and this year’s winter dragged on with no early spring. 39:40
- Answer: Don agrees many factors combine, with early spring and warm temperatures being good for antler growth. 40:03
- Answer: Don advises Carl not to give up on the buck, since a lack of jump from three to four doesn’t mean it won’t happen from four to five. 43:41
Question: Terry asked Don to confirm that every deer is different and peaks in antler growth at different times. 42:49 — asked by Terry — Episode #140 - Fall Drought - What does that mean for deer hunters?
- Answer: Don confirms it, noting some deer peak as early as three and a half years old. 42:57
Question: Terry asked whether Don had shot any does the year before Mel and a similar buck were fawns. 23:23 — Episode #135 - Buck Dispersal - What does it mean?
- Answer: Don said he didn’t shoot any does that year, since through 2011 he was targeting two does for every buck taken on his place. 23:37
- Answer: Don said after EHD devastated his herd in 2012 he stopped shooting does until finally shooting one again last season. 23:57
Question: Ryan Turner asks whether nutrition and habitat work he does for buck fawns mainly ends up benefiting neighboring properties once bucks disperse. 68:31 — asked by Ryan Turner — Chasing Giants Episode 121 - Residual Herbicide Discussion & Don is Buying a Farm
- Answer: Don explains research shows that if the mother doe is harvested, her buck fawn stays near its birth area about 90% of the time instead of dispersing. 69:06
Question: Justin Rice from Poynette, Wisconsin asks when Don and Terry first noticed more older age-class bucks and whether their management influenced neighboring bucks. 60:00 — asked by Justin Rice — Episode #115 - Don’s Top Four Properties Visited This Year
- Answer: Don says his property management undoubtedly influences mature buck numbers for about a mile around his farm. 60:28
- Answer: Terry adds that after minimizing pressure and maximizing food and cover on his small Kentucky properties, he began getting shots at bucks five or six years old or older. 64:01
- Answer: Terry emphasizes that hunters must establish age structure before focusing on antler size, or their chances of a giant buck are much smaller. 64:37
Question: An audience member asked whether the farm’s two mounted elite whitetails have any bearing on the policy of shooting does with twin button bucks. 27:39 — Episode #110 - Double Episode live from Master Class - Al Foster gives great advise
- Answer: Don said the only two does shot on his farm since 2011 were taken because they had twin buck fawns, and he doesn’t think the mounted bucks were affected by that policy. 28:45
Question: The audience member asked whether having two 200-inch bucks (Mel and Smokey) on the farm influences the decision to shoot does with twin button bucks. 29:10 — Episode #110 - Double Episode live from Master Class - Al Foster gives great advise
- Answer: Don said giant deer are too rare to manage for; you can raise a farm’s overall antler quality but can’t specifically manage to produce a 200-inch buck. 30:41
Question: James from Fredericksburg, Ohio asked how to determine doe population and the number needed to correct the buck-to-doe ratio. 42:00 — asked by James — Episode #110 - Double Episode live from Master Class - Al Foster gives great advise
- Answer: Don said unless management happens over a wide area, shooting 20 does just causes 30 more to move in from neighboring properties to replace them. 42:35
Question: An audience member (Jordan) described culling a buck that put on over 60 inches of antler in one year and asked how you’d avoid shooting a future giant like it. 128:37 — Episode #110 - Double Episode live from Master Class - Al Foster gives great advise
- Answer: Don said you can’t know for certain; he plays the odds, since a buck scoring 150 at age three is far likelier to reach 200 than one scoring 120. 129:15
- Answer: Terry called it a statistical ‘unicorn,’ since he knows of no other wild deer adding 60 inches in a year, and said you can’t let a thousand eight-pointers walk chasing that outlier. 129:31
Question: Is it better to kill does before or after the rut when harvesting for meat? 72:10 — EPISODE #109 SHED HUNTING and LIVE FROM MASTER CLASS #2
- Answer: Don prefers to wait until after the rut, in the late season, to shoot does. 72:57
Question: Has anyone considered identifying and removing a specific doe to prevent her from passing on an unwanted gene? 48:50 — asked by Chris Hyatt — Episode #108 - Mind Blowing Deer Management with Dr. Bronson Strickland
- Answer: Bronson says you cannot manage genetics that way; culling a doe is only justified for behavioral reasons, not genetic control. 49:18
Question: A newer land manager in the Carolinas asks the panel to explain doe-to-buck ratio for beginners and when he should be killing more does. 46:57 — EPISODE #107 - Don Knows How To Fire Up Southern Folks!
- Answer: Don says rather than a 1:1 or 2:1 buck-to-doe ratio, he prefers around five or six does per buck so resident bucks don’t roam to neighboring properties. 47:49
Question: An audience member asks whether a herd’s protective lead doe that alerts other deer becomes a liability or remains an asset to hunters targeting larger bucks. 49:41 — EPISODE #107 - Don Knows How To Fire Up Southern Folks!
- Answer: Don says such a protective lead doe more often hurts his chances of killing a buck than she helps, so he would try to remove her from the herd. 50:08
- Answer: Terry adds that shooting the lead doe in the exact spot meant for a mature buck can flood the sanctuary with pressure, causing more harm than good. 52:05
Question: Larry Beachy asked how long Don managed his wild deer population before starting to cull younger bucks. 21:48 — asked by Larry Beachy — Episode #105 Live from Shipshewana, IN - 2 Episodes in One!
- Answer: Don has managed his property for whitetails for about thirty years, culling hard for roughly the last ten. 22:22
- Answer: An EHD outbreak in 2012 wiped out about 75% of Don’s local deer herd. 23:00
- Answer: After the herd rebounded with better genetics, Don shot Smokey (206 inches) in 2017 and Mel (221 inches) in 2020. 23:16
Question: Paul Troyer asked whether he should have shot a doe with triplet button bucks to keep them around. 113:24 — asked by Paul Troyer — Episode #105 Live from Shipshewana, IN - 2 Episodes in One!
- Answer: Don cited research by Dr. Carl Miller at the University of Georgia on button buck dispersal. 113:39
- Answer: That research found bucks typically disperse five to twenty miles from their birthplace. 114:02
- Answer: If the mother doe is killed, 90% of the time her buck fawns stay near where they were born, so Don confirmed Paul should have shot that doe. 114:26
Question: John Miller asked what buck-to-doe ratio Don maintains and whether too many does is a problem. 129:46 — asked by John Miller — Episode #105 Live from Shipshewana, IN - 2 Episodes in One!
- Answer: Don said too many does can be a problem elsewhere, but his low-deer-density area has never required worrying about ratio. 129:54
Question: Ethan Olson asked why his mature bucks leave his 330-acre property once pre-rut hits, despite holding older bucks earlier in the year. 41:15 — asked by Ethan Olson — Episode #96 - STAY OUT OF THE SANCTUARY!
- Answer: Don said Ethan had bought into the ‘doe factory’ myth; shooting too many does pressures the property and drives off security-seeking bucks. 42:52
Question: Josh Anderson asked whether hunters should let prime bucks survive the rut to breed again and target them in the late season instead. 57:51 — Episode #96 - STAY OUT OF THE SANCTUARY!
- Answer: Don explained a buck’s genetics and ability to produce healthy offspring don’t change with age, though he liked the idea of letting prime bucks breed and shooting them late season. 58:09
Question: If cull bucks and small yearlings are left to breed the does every year, what happens to the doe herd’s quality over time? 25:15 — Episode #95 - Live from Guthrie, KY
- Answer: Don explained that on a managed property you can dictate which bucks in each age class survive to the next age class, unlike the wild herd overall. 26:56
Question: With an abundant doe herd, what part of the season is best for taking does? 40:54 — Episode #95 - Live from Guthrie, KY
- Answer: Don said the more important question is where to shoot does—away from the core property—rather than when. 41:11
Question: Jeremy Melville asked whether Don lets family and friends shoot three-to-four-year-old eight pointers to give them opportunities, or to remove deer unlikely to score high later. 58:54 — asked by Jeremy Melville — Episode #92 - Don in Facebook Jail?
- Answer: Don confirms both reasons apply: three-to-four-year-old eight pointers rarely become top-scoring bucks, so removing them helps management while giving family and friends a rewarding hunt. 59:10
Question: Rob from Ada, Michigan asked whether to keep aggressively harvesting does on his ‘fall doe factory’ property, and how to bring bucks back for fall. 42:53 — asked by Rob — Episode #89 - 2021 Rut Setting Up To Be FANTASTIC!
- Answer: Don advised Rob to eliminate human intrusion, stop worrying about doe numbers since uncooperative neighbors negate the effort, and give bucks security to draw them back. 45:47
Question: Terry asks Brent what his goal is for hunting Don’s property. 11:19 — asked by Terry — Episode #85 - The Ones That Got Away… New Series by Don
- Answer: Brent’s goal is simply to kill a buck at least three and a half years old, something he has never done before. 11:29
Question: Kyle Bliss asks why Don wouldn’t consider shooting a buck that’s regressed from one-seventies to one-sixties inches this year. 41:33 — asked by Kyle Bliss — Episode #84 Don Choice - Iowa or Illinois for Opening Day?
- Answer: Don says he’s giving the eight-and-a-half-year-old buck one more year, citing a Clark County buck that grew its biggest rack at nine and a half. 42:08
Question: Jonathan Joyce also asks what Don’s management approach is toward deer with odd, offset-looking racks. 46:22 — asked by Jonathan Joyce — Episode #84 Don Choice - Iowa or Illinois for Opening Day?
- Answer: Don says if the odd rack is genetic, like one-sided spike bucks, he tries to eliminate them from the herd, but he doesn’t worry about injury-caused racks. 50:03
Question: Daryl Nestle from Shreve, Ohio asks how to tell if a young buck has the potential to become a giant. 45:56 — asked by Daryl Nestle — Episode #79 - Bachelor Group Dispersal and Iowa Update
- Answer: Don says generally the more points a deer carries when young, the more points he’ll carry as he ages. 46:10
- Answer: Don explains he removes smooth-rack eight-pointers from his property since most never develop into giants. 46:41
Question: Ray South from Oakwood, Illinois asked Don to explain the benefits of trapping coyotes for protecting fawns. 45:46 — asked by Ray South — Episode #65 Spring Plot Herbicide Discussion and Fawns dropping
- Answer: Don shared that hiring a trapper who caught 14 coyotes, plus 3 he shot by bow and more by rifle, dramatically improved fawn recruitment on his farm. 47:10
Question: Lewis asks whether a property can have too many does. 53:27 — asked by Lewis — Episode #61 - Live from the Midwest Sportsman Show - TOUGH QUESTIONS FROM LIVE CROWD
- Answer: Don confirms a property can have too many does, but says the real question is whether anything can be done about it. 53:38
- Answer: Don warns that shooting does without neighborhood-wide management just invites more deer in, defeating the effort. 54:14
Question: Terry relays a listener’s question asking whether too many does will push a buck off the property. 63:51 — Episode #61 - Live from the Midwest Sportsman Show - TOUGH QUESTIONS FROM LIVE CROWD
- Answer: Don says no, buck movement off a property is governed by human intrusion and pressure, not doe numbers. 63:58
Question: Matt asks whether Don and Terry have a doe management plan and whether shooting does matters for growing big bucks. 61:53 — asked by Matt — Episode #57 - Discussion about Ethics Continues as guest at the 2nd Master Class put Don on the spot with live questions.
- Answer: Don says he doesn’t shoot many does on his property because the herd isn’t at a point requiring it. 62:03
Question: Should hunters cull a smaller-antlered one-year-old buck instead of a bigger one-year-old, or is predicting future antler growth still a crapshoot? 53:55 — asked by Clayton Rent — Episode #53 - Iowa Deer Classic, Deer Foundering, Cull Bucks, and Don gets fired up about politics at the end
- Answer: Don advises against culling yearling bucks for management purposes, noting birth-date variation skews first-year antlers, though the best buck in an age class tends to stay best. 54:15
Question: Greg Neese asks whether shooting does early risks killing mature buck fawns, and which doe age class is best to harvest for buck herd health. 44:02 — asked by Greg Neese — Episode 51 - Serving the Hunting Community instead of using the Hunting Industry
- Answer: Don says he personally prefers to shoot does late in the season to avoid pressuring his farm and tracking deer into the sanctuary early. 45:40
- Answer: Don personally targets does with twin buck fawns, which are usually the older mature does in the herd. 47:47
Question: Since our DNR zone only allows harvesting one deer per hunter per year, should we be concerned our doe numbers will get too high? 53:41 — asked by Matt — #49 - Nutrition: Proteins vs. Fat / Macro and Micro nutrients in Mineral - Know what you need!
- Answer: Don says state DNR agencies are well tuned to their deer herds and will adjust regulations if doe numbers get out of line, so it likely isn’t an issue yet. 54:45
- Answer: Terry agrees hunters often panic too quickly about needing to shoot does when they’re really just seeing extra deer drawn in by good food plots. 57:35
Question: Given that super does pass on their father’s genetics, what’s the best way to harvest a doe for herd management without removing a good gene-pool doe? 58:12 — asked by Bob Longo — #49 - Nutrition: Proteins vs. Fat / Macro and Micro nutrients in Mineral - Know what you need!
- Answer: Don says there’s no way to visually identify a doe’s genetic quality in the wild, so his practical rule is to harvest the doe traveling with button buck fawns. 59:09
Question: Casey Virgin asked how aggressively Don would run a cull program on mature bucks unlikely to become desirable trophies. 37:53 — asked by Casey Virgin — Episode #36 Peak Rut Update, Warm Weather, maybe a little election and religion
- Answer: Don explained that, per Bronson Strickland’s research, hunters typically shoot the best-genetic buck in each age class first, which is why he culls the opposite way. 40:35
- Answer: Don said he culls hard, removing roughly ten bucks a year from his 120-acre farm to favor better genetics. 42:30
- Answer: Terry suggested Casey recruit a veteran or a kid hunter to shoot the cull bucks, turning the mop-up work into a positive experience for someone else. 45:44
Question: Don asks whether selectively culling the smallest-antlered bucks in each age class on a single property can meaningfully improve its buck quality. 60:07 — asked by Don — Episode #31 - Special Guest Dr. Bronson Strickland - Fetal Programming, Deer Dispersal, Minerals, and CWD
- Answer: Strickland strongly agrees, noting he and Steve Demarais wrote a book on this ‘strategic harvest system’ endorsing culling below-average bucks old enough to predict they won’t become trophies. 60:23
Question: Bob asks how to identify which does should be culled versus kept when managing herd ratio, given uncertainty about doe genetics. 48:40 — Episode #27 Season is closing in. Final prep work is being done along with addressing some hurt feelings.
- Answer: Don’s rule of thumb: whenever a hunter can shoot a doe accompanied by two button bucks, take it, since that removes buck fawns least likely to disperse. 52:39
- Answer: Terry recommends setting up separate feeding spots away from target-buck stand sites specifically for doe harvest, to avoid pressuring prime hunting areas. 53:19
Question: Amos Hershberger asks what Don thinks about culling bucks that don’t show potential as two- or three-year-olds. 23:04 — asked by Amos Hershberger — Episode #26 - Don tackles two controversial topics CULLING and AGING BUCKS
- Answer: Don agrees with experts that culling cannot change a wild deer herd’s genetics, since deer disperse too widely across the landscape. 25:28
- Answer: Don explains that the best yearling bucks are almost always the best two-year-olds, and that trend continues through each older age class. 30:03
Question: Bryan asks Don what his number one deer management technique has been. 21:01 — asked by Bryan Medinger — Episode #22 - Special Contest Winner Bryan Medinger and Don has big announcement
- Answer: Don says limiting human intrusion is the number one deer management factor since intrusion ruins properties more than anything else. 22:12
Question: Jacob Wessels of Fairbury, Illinois asks whether antler point restrictions do more harm than good and if Don would encourage Illinois DNR to implement them. 49:39 — asked by Jacob Wessels — Episode #7 - Hunting during lock down - Things do not always go easy in the “Real World”
- Answer: Don answers no, he would not encourage the Illinois DNR or any state agency to implement antler point restrictions. 50:24
- Answer: Don points to Iowa and Ohio, which hold firearm seasons after the rut in early December, as proof that season timing manages age structure better than antler restrictions. 52:00
Question: Are you concerned about maintaining a specific buck-to-doe ratio on your hunting properties? 34:00 — Episode #5 - November is Here!
- Answer: Don says no, since his properties are too small for him alone to affect the ratio without neighboring cooperation. 34:05
- Answer: After EHD devastated the herd, Don decided to rebuild it by not shooting or allowing any does on his property since 2011. 35:05
Unofficial fan project. AI-synthesized from public episodes; may contain errors.